The Universal Issue

Accusation

The controversy over the death of Trayvon Martin, shot by George Zimmerman, has many unanswered questions and underlying themes to the scandal. A main universal question was whether Zimmerman shot Martin because it was self-defense, or because he was black and “suspicious”. CNN presented an article by Greg Botelho and Holly Yan testifying that “A 911 dispatcher told Zimmerman that officers were on the way and not to follow the allegedly suspicious person. But Zimmerman still got out of his car…” (Botelho). Zimmerman’s lawyer Mark O’Mara stated “I think things would have been different if George Zimmerman were black for this reason: He never would have been charged with a crime” (Botelho). These racial disputes caused many people to take a side. Another racial question that was brought to attention was that there were six jurors “…all of them women—deliberated for 16 ½ hours. Five of the women are white; one is a minority” (Botelho). The main theme/similarity between these questions was racial discrimination, whether it be between Zimmerman and Martin or the race of the jury. Most of these questions suggest that decisions made in this case were strongly influenced by hatred between races.

            After researching the case and seeing questions from all different types of people, these questions were very relevant and accurate. It was said later in the article that Martin attacked Zimmerman by jumping out of a bush, but even if that were to be true, Zimmerman was informed not to get out of the car and he still did anyways, bringing the alleged “attack” upon himself. The question of the race of the jury and whether Zimmerman would be prosecuted if he were black both refer to racial hatred in the same way. I agree with both questions because I’ve seen real life examples of both. Saying that a mostly Caucasian jury rules that a Caucasian/Hispanic man is not guilty for murdering an African American man, and saying that an African American man wouldn’t be prosecuted for shooting another African American man both imply that races stick together. That’s what most people have been taught growing up, stick to your race no matter what. Having said that, I do agree with those questions being asked but I do not agree with the implication and assumption that all people are prone to do that.

            The most important question to the verdict would be whether Zimmerman shot Martin in self-defense or because he was “suspicious”. No matter what the reason was for Zimmerman shooting Martin “…the foundation really stands for getting people to understand that violence is not the answer” (Stewart). Whether Martin attacked Zimmerman or Martin just shot him because he “wanted to”, violence will only make matters worse.

 

Botelho, Greg. Yan, Holly. “George Zimmerman found not guilty of murder in Trayvon Martin’s death.” CNN Justice. CNN, 14 July 2013. Web. 14 July 2014. <http://www.cnn.com/2013/07/13/justice/zimmerman-trial/&gt;.

Stewart, Ayana. “Florida Memorial University is now home to Trayvon Martin Foundation.” Miami Herald [Miami] 26 June 2014: 3. Print.

 

Kendall Kramer

Advertisements

2 thoughts on “The Universal Issue

  1. I think your essay was well written!! You really took advantage of logical appeal and provided the audience with effective background information. I knew absolutely nothing about the Trayvon Martin case and your essay intrigued me. After reading it, I decided I would look into the case and learn more about it. Your referencing was awesome! Like I’ve said before in others’ comments, referencing is one of my weaknesses and I think you did an awesome job. I like that you added the jury’s race into your augment, I find it to be really effective. It really contributed to the essay. Well done!

  2. I really liked your blog because it mentioned some things I didn’t even know about the case. For instance, I didn’t know that Zimmerman’s lawyer had said that racial statement. Also, I never knew about the jury and the difference from whites to one minority. I like how you stated the questions, but also gave your own opinion in response. Your blog had a lot of good points, nice job!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s